Latest Headlines
Hunger and Yari’s Poverty of Thought

The Advocate By Onikepo Braithwaite Onikepo.braithwaite@thisdaylive.com
The Advocate
By Onikepo Braithwaite
Onikepo.braithwaite@thisdaylive.com
“If there’s no food in the market, that’s what we are calling hunger. But, anyone who is not a lazy person, definitely, he would have food on his table.” – Senator Abdul’aziz Abubakar Yari, APC Senator representing Zamfara West, Governor, Zamfara State 2011-2019, APC Rally, Uyo, November, 2026
Senator Yari’s Faux-Pas
As we say in Yoruba, “Senator Yari lenu e?!” – “Senator Yari, from your mouth?!” – meaning that such a statement should certainly not be coming from him. I’m a firm believer in keeping quiet, when one doesn’t have anything useful or edifying to say. It is better. The All Progressives Congress Presidential Campaign Council (APC PCC) too, obviously realises this. If not, the PCC wouldn’t have issued a statement restricting the number of those who can speak on its behalf, to a few. But, it shouldn’t only be concerned about interviews given by their PCC or Party members that turn out to be absurd and/or embarrassing, they should also monitor what the people who campaign at rallies also say. I do agree that Section 39(1) of the 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (as amended)(the Constitution) guarantees the right to freedom of expression, but when comments in the name of campaign end up insulting and riling the same people whom they are trying to attract the votes of, such tactlessness may end up being counterproductive, and impacting negatively on the chances of the very candidates they are campaigning for.
How can anyone insinuate that the millions of Nigerians who are unable to put food on their tables, are unable to do so because they are lazy? And, coming from the Director-General of APC’s PCC, this is such an inaccurate, uncharitable and unkind statement to make about the people, especially when majority of politicians today are unable to account for their own sources of income. Some politicians are reputed to be fabulously wealthy, yet, they have no visible means of income apart from State funds and State resources. It is gaslighting of the highest order, to shift blame from the politicians who are responsible for the people’s plight due to the failure of governance, whether as a result of ineptitude or corruption, whatever the reasons, onto the people.
Then, a former Governor and sitting Senator of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, the highest lawmaking body in the land, apart from being unable to define a word as simple as Hunger, indirectly states publicly, that only lazy people cannot put food on their tables! This is one of the most insensitive statements, that I have heard in a while. Without taking any blame for how, over the years, successive administrations (present company included), have failed to fulfil the Fundamental Objectives and Directive Principles of State Policy stated in Chapter II of the Constitution, which has led to the poor condition that majority of Nigerians are in today, from the failure to abolish corrupt practices and abuse of power, to the failure to harness the resources of Nigeria for the benefit, welfare, prosperity and happiness of Nigerians, but instead harnessing them into the individual pockets of a few, to a high rate of unemployment, so much so that University graduates are constrained to do menial jobs, to the failure to pay workers a reasonable national minimum living wage (see Sections 15(5) & 16 of the Constitution) – these failures in governance are some of the reasons why Nigerians are hungry, not laziness. See AG Ondo v AGF & Ors (2002) LPELR-623(SC).
Definition of Hunger
According to the Oxford Advanced Learner’s Dictionary, hunger is defined as: “The feeling caused by a need to eat. Severe lack of food: The state of not having enough food to eat, which can cause illness or death (synonymous with starvation)”. Hunger certainly doesn’t mean, no food in the market. When there’s no food in the market, it’s referred to as a food shortage, food scarcity or food unavailability. When the food scarcity is extreme, probably caused by famine or drought, or in Nigeria, insecurity which prevents people from farming, it becomes a food crisis that can cause the people to face starvation. So, to start with, Senator Yari’s definition of hunger is incorrect.
In the Nigerian context, hunger is directly linked to the non-affordability of food; not having enough food to eat, because the reality is that, people simply do not have the funds to feed adequately. Recall the mathematical equation coined by University students around 2009, to describe the struggle to afford three square meals day? With the number 1 signifying having a meal? 100 – only breakfast; 001 – only dinner; 000 – no meals. It spread from Universities into broader Nigerian discourse, as economic pressures and insecurity made skipping meals more widespread. By 2020, the terms appeared in mainstream reporting on household coping strategies, and even statements by labour leaders describing people on 010 or similar patterns.
The Second Half of Senator Yari’s Statement
We must then interrogate the second half of Yari’s statement – that only lazy Nigerians are unable to put food on their tables. Our founding Fathers, like the Sardauna of Sokoto, Sir Ahmadu Bello, GCON, KBE, who is said to have had something like £10 in his account at the time of his death, and Chief Obafemi Awolowo, GCFR, SAN, the father of free quality education, are probably somersaulting in their graves, seeing how the standard of living of Nigerians has generally declined during the Fourth Republic.
Senator Yari, having served as a two-term Governor of Zamfara State from May 2011 to May 2019, has played a significant part in government and governance. Zamfara State, amidst its wealth in resources such as Gold, remained one of the poorest States in Nigeria during Yari’s tenure, by the end of which, in 2018/2019, the National Bureau of Statistics Living Standards Survey data put Zamfara’s poverty head count at almost 74%. Multidimensional poverty indicators, were similarly elevated. The State received substantial revenues over the years, but showed limited progress in reducing extreme poverty, or raising living standards relative to its challenges. Insecurity was one of the most damaging features of Yari’s tenure. Farmer-herder conflicts, illegal mining, and other factors fed into organised banditry that escalated sharply, especially in Yari’s second term. There were mass killings, kidnappings, and rural terror. Some even referred to Zamfara, as a “Colony of Banditry”.
It is necessary to give this background, to make it easier for Nigerians to understand that such a statement shouldn’t emanate from someone who did little or nothing to eradicate poverty in his State, when he had the opportunity to make a difference. His acts, omissions, failures and neglect have certainly contributed in no small measure, to many Zamfarans being unable to put food on their tables.
Though Section 16(2)(d) of the Constitution provides inter alia that people must be paid a reasonable national minimum living wage, through the Fourth Republic, this hasn’t really happened. Politicians are paid exorbitant wages and perquisites that they don’t deserve, while workers are underpaid. Primary School Teachers and Local Government workers in Zamfara remained on extremely low pay scales, with Nigeria Labour Congress (NLC) repeatedly citing figures in the N7,000–N8,000 per month range under past administrations! Some 2014 Teacher recruits went unpaid for extended periods, while Pension backlogs accumulated throughout Yari’s eight years in office. Imagine, Yari was paying workers below the minimum wage of the 2011 N18,000 throughout his tenure; this is both unconstitutional and unlawful. See Section 2-4 of the National Minimum Wage Act 2019 (as amended in 2024). The 2019 increase to N30,000 minimum wage came in April 2019, roughly a month before Yari’s tenure as Governor ended – this increase was not implemented in his time, nor that of his successor, Bello Maitawalle.
This was the position in Zamfara, until Governor Dauda Lawal assumed office and people started to see some change. Will we then call the underpaid Teachers and Local Government workers, or Teachers and Pensioners in Zamfara who were owed their meagre salaries by Yari’s administration, lazy? I think not. It was the fault of the then Zamfara State Government, that these workers were unable to put food on their tables.
Can you call a Medical Doctor in Nigeria who saves lives on a daily basis, works long hours, even does night duty regularly, earns N300,000 monthly and is unable to feed his/her family, pay school fees in a decent school for two children, lazy?! I think not. Such a person is underpaid. Can you call a worker who works full-time and earns the N70,000 minimum wage, lazy or underpaid? In that N70,000, the worker is meant to pay for transport to get to and from work from Monday to Friday, feed themselves and family, even if their children go to public schools, there are costs involved, how realistic is this? Recently, a friend of mine was telling me that his company was short-staffed, because most of the construction workers wanted to live-in to be able to save on transportation costs, and only go home at the weekends instead of daily.
As Governor of Zamfara State, though some infrastructure gains, including the development of road networks, have been attributed to Yari’s tenure as Governor, we do not know at what cost these projects were undertaken. That, over the years, the cost of most of the infrastructure projects in Nigeria have always been inflated, is not breaking news. This is one of the ways that Government officials enrich themselves and put sumptuous food on their own tables, while majority suffer and go hungry. Does this make them more hardworking than the masses? Absolutely not!
Conclusion
Senator Yari’s statement is not merely a verbal slip; it is a refusal to accept responsibility for the consequences of the failure of governance, of which he is part and parcel of. The Constitution’s Chapter II objectives — the abolition of corrupt practices, the harnessing of national resources for the welfare and prosperity of the people, and the payment of a reasonable living wage — have remained largely aspirational, with Section 6(6)(c) of the Constitution which makes Chapter II non-justiciable, providing politicians with an easy escape route from accountability for their failure. When a two-term Governor whose State recorded poverty rates approaching 74%, unpaid salaries, and escalating banditry, later attributes the inability of millions to put food on their tables to laziness, the claim collapses under the weight of his own record.
Hunger in contemporary Nigeria is primarily a question of non-affordability, produced by policy choices, insecurity that keeps farmers off the land, and a wage structure that leaves even full-time workers unable to meet basic needs. The student-devised equation of 100, 001 or 000 is simply the arithmetic expression of that reality.
Until those who have held high office can demonstrate that they used the resources and authority available to them to reduce, rather than preside over widespread poverty, statements that shift blame onto the governed will continue to ring hollow and sound offensive. Public office carries a duty of care; when that duty is unmet, it is not just a falsehood but disparaging, to re-describe the people’s resulting hunger as laziness and/or the fault of the hungry.






