Latest Headlines
The Rigging Narrative and the 2027 Presidential Poll
Postscript by Waziri Adio
Even by the low bar set in the seven election cycles since 1999, the campaign for the 2027 presidential election has been peculiarly dull. The first half of the overly generous five-month campaign window featured little more than media interviews and social media posts by the leading presidential candidates. The campaign machines only started cranking to life towards the end of the third month, with processions, town halls and rallies becoming more frequent.
Yet it still doesn’t feel like we are just two months away from a high-stakes presidential poll. In an election that should be a robust contest of ideas about the state and direction of the country, two of the top three presidential candidates are yet to unveil their policy blueprints, and some of their cerebral supporters have even tried to downplay the importance of manifestos in elections and governance. However, one thing has stood out boldly in this low-intensity campaign season: the strident narrative about rigging.
Rigging, and claims of it, are not new to Nigeria’s elections. There is a popular saying that Nigerian politicians don’t lose elections; they are always rigged out. The unwillingness to accept defeat, even when it is glaring, is one of the distinguishing features of our still-maturing political culture. This, though, is not to say that all claims of rigging are baseless. We have seen different forms of electoral manipulation in this country, from the subtle to the blatant: underage and community voting, ballot stuffing and swapping, and the outright writing of results. In fact, there is a widely held belief that all politicians try to rig where they can, especially in their strongholds, because they expect their opponents to do the same. This is our electoral version of the prisoner’s dilemma.
But it is also true that we have made progress in reducing, though not eliminating, electoral heists. Evidence-based litigation has reduced the utility of multiple voting and of changing or rewriting election results. Electoral reforms of the last two decades, especially the use of technology for voter registration and accreditation, have also significantly narrowed the room for electoral mischief. One unintended effect of these reforms is that vote trading, itself not particularly new, has come back into play. The egregious forms of rigging carried out as recently as 2003 and 2007 are more difficult to pull off today. Without a doubt, there is still room for growth in making our elections freer, fairer and more credible. But it is undeniable that significant progress has been made and that final results now largely reflect the overall voting pattern across the country.
If this is the case, why is the claim of probable rigging the dominant narrative of the 2027 election cycle? One quick answer is recent history. In the 2023 cycle, the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) fancied that it had found the magic bullet for finally eradicating rigging in Nigeria. It promised that results from polling units would be available to the public “in real time” on the INEC Result Viewing portal (IReV). The promise tapped into the widespread belief that election results were still being manipulated at collation centres. INEC thought that making raw results visible to Nigerians would be the game-changer, and it sold the idea vigorously.
It can be argued that the idea was oversold. Each participating political party is expected to have agents in all 176,846 polling units across the country, to be in possession of duly signed results from all the polling units, and to have agents at every collation centre, from the ward and local government levels to the state and federal levels. The system established by law provides room for checks and balances and for gathering credible evidence that can be used to seek redress, if necessary. It is not a perfect system, but it is not as broken as it is sometimes made to appear. However, INEC nailed the credibility of the 2023 election to the mast of results displayed on IReV.
INEC asked Nigerians to believe, and most Nigerians believed the electoral umpire. So, when IReV either malfunctioned or was switched off (depending on whom you listen to), it was proof positive for many that the election had been rigged. IReV was designed to validate, not replace, the paper results which all participating parties should have, signed by the presiding officers and the agents of the political parties. But INEC itself had, wittingly or unwittingly, helped to cement the narrative that the established way of tabulating election results was not credible enough. Irrespective of what the paper results showed, and despite the fact that a divided opposition created a path for the eventual winner, the conclusion in certain camps was that the 2023 election was stolen. And the reasoning goes that if that election was stolen, future elections are susceptible to the same fate.
The second reason is related. Some candidates and their supporters have sold themselves on the idea that the only way they can lose the 2027 presidential election is if they are rigged out. This belief rests on a number of assumptions. One, that they would have won in 2023 but for rigging, and that they could not prove their case because the electoral and judicial systems conspired against them. Two, that Nigerians are united in electing anyone but the incumbent president. And three, that the incumbent’s only path to victory is through rigging. But these assumptions cannot stand serious scrutiny.
As Simon Kolawole makes clear in his insightful book on the 2023 presidential election, “Winning Formula”, Nigerian voters juggle a number of considerations, and a credible, cross-regional electoral coalition is the basic minimum for winning the Nigerian presidency. Localised, near-cultic adulation, as we have seen from Chief Obafemi Awolowo to Mallam Aminu Kano and General Muhammadu Buhari in the past, are by themselves not enough. Besides, financial resources and political structure play a big role in deciding electoral outcomes in a large and diverse country like Nigeria. Assuming that all Nigerians are united in voting out the incumbent ignores not only the peculiar dynamics of our electoral politics but also the fact that not everyone may be convinced, for different reasons, about the other leading candidates and what they have to offer. Then there is the not-so-small matter of a fragmented opposition. A united opposition does not by itself guarantee victory, but it at least improves the opposition’s chances. Likewise, a divided opposition does not guarantee success for the incumbent, but it does open a path.
The third reason the rigging narrative may be of high value in some circles is that it can be a useful mobilisation and pre-emptive tool. It can be a way of telling supporters that victory is achievable if they keep the faith, turn out in large numbers and protect their votes. It can also put the ruling party and all state institutions involved in conducting elections on notice that manipulation will be strongly resisted. All this is in order. We need Nigerians to take more interest in elections, and we need our elections to be of the highest standard.
Ensuring that votes count, and using technology for quick tabulation of declared results, as some have promised to do, should be encouraged, as long as such technology is not used to manipulate results. We should do everything to increase the transparency and credibility of our elections so that the winner and the losers are clear to all. We should also encourage results to be vigorously contested, but on the basis of evidence and through the established channels, not through self-help if the process produces a result some people don’t like.
This is where some of the dark rhetoric around rigging becomes worrisome. There is a fine line between mobilising supporters to turn out and be vigilant, and inciting them to violence. Expressions such as “rig and die” or “rig and roast”, and practices such as brandishing machetes or arrows at campaign events, clearly cross that line. The usual comeback from those who should know better, but who encourage such dangerous sayings and practices, is that anyone who has no plans to rig, or does not support rigging, should have nothing to fear. This is extremely lame.
It might all sound like fun, or just pre-emptive tough talk, until someone actually takes it upon themselves to hack down another person who, in their judgement, has rigged the election or collaborated with riggers. Once started, violence takes on a life of its own, and it is often easier to strike the match than to put out the fire.
Any post-election violence in 2027 is likely to be of a different hue from the episodes that roiled the western part of the country in 1964/1965 and 1983, and some parts of the north in 2011. This is because of the ethnic configuration of the 2027 contest and the worsening of inter-ethnic relations in the country in recent years. Unlike in the past, the fire this time may not be confined to just a zone or section of the country; it may engulf the whole country. Many innocent Nigerians may be caught in the fray simply because of their ethnicity or their looks. Needless to say, the party leaders and the intellectuals encouraging and justifying violence are unlikely to be on the receiving end. Their families are also likely to be far away from the frontlines.
As a teenager, I experienced the post-election violence of 1983 first-hand. Party members incited by their leaders gathered in groups in many parts of my town. The rampage started in one part, and others followed. The rioters set houses and property on fire. They necklaced and burnt fellow human beings. Young as I was, I was spirited away to another part of town and hidden under a bed for days because some members of my family (who had the good sense to skip town at the earliest hint of trouble) were suspected of voting for “the wrong party”. It is a trauma that decades have not wiped away. I can say for free that the violence some of our friends speak about so glibly is not as sexy and as discriminating as they think. This is not meant to scare anyone or to stop people from following their convictions. But we can work for credible elections and campaign vigorously for our preferred candidates while avoiding careless, dangerous talk.






