Stabilizing the Naira

14
8220

GUEST COLUNMIST BY DAVID EDEVBIE

Our economy did well in the last decade with the average GDP growth rate between 2005 and 2015 reaching an impressive 5.9%. Notwithstanding, the economy is still in the doldrums as it struggles to cope with a myriad of economic challenges. Lately, global oil revenues have declined due to a fall in prices, which plunged below US$30 per barrel in early 2016 for the first time in 12 years. As the petroleum sector contributes approximately 11% to our economy and oil exports currently constitutes about 90% of our export revenues, the effect on our nation’s income has been devastating. Revenue available to governments at all levels has plummeted with most state and local governments unable to pay the salaries of public servants at the moment.

As a result of the decline in international oil prices and the attendant effect on our foreign exchange earnings, the pressure to devalue our currency is mounting daily. However, we are not alone in this quagmire. On March 14, 2016, the Central Bank of Egypt further devalued the Egyptian Pound by 13 per cent against the US Dollar. This announcement followed similar devaluations of national currencies by Russia, Venezuela, Kazakhstan and Azerbaijan in response to the severe economic pressures that these countries were facing. Several other Gulf States are also experiencing intense pressure on their currencies.

However unlike Nigeria, countries such as Saudi Arabia, Oman and Bahrain have significant foreign reserves which may help them stabilize their currencies without undue strain in the short term.
According to CBN, our external reserves have fallen to about $27.88 billion as at March 2016. This represents approximately a 65% decline in reserves from about $42.8 billion in 2014. At the moment our foreign reserves is equivalent to just five months import cover.

A key reason for the depletion of our external reserves over time is the high rate of domestic demand for foreign exchange which has steadily risen over the years, severely straining the capacity of the Central Bank to meet it. Domestic demand is fueled by importation of petroleum products; auction sales to BDCs, banks and other government agencies to fund foreign exchange requests for imports, foreign school fees, personal travel allowance (PTA), business travel allowance (BTA), medical tourism and international card transactions; Joint venture cash call payments; Public sector uses and infrastructural development.

As demand exceeds the supply of foreign exchange and the CBN continues to maintain a narrow fixed exchange rate band for the Naira to US dollar of between N197-N199, it has had to use its external reserves to meet the excess demand and defend the value of the naira. Suffice to note here that several countries have either experimented with fixed rate regimes or have tried at one time or the other to exert artificial influence over the exchange rates of their national currencies and failed. Japan and Switzerland are classic examples.

These failures are also a clear indication that adjusting monetary policy only without corresponding action on fiscal policy is unlikely to produce the desired effect of exchange rate stabilization. Indeed, fiscal policy must be adjusted to shift the fundamentals of the economy in the intended direction.

The Central Bank announced a number of measures in June 2015 in a bid to introduce stability in the nation’s currency in response to the effects of dwindling foreign exchange earnings. Several administrative controls were put in place. One of these was the removal of 41 imported items from the list of commodities for which foreign exchange could be obtained from the CBN for the purpose of importation. February 2015 saw the stoppage of foreign exchange sales to BDCs by the apex bank and the closure of the Wholesale and Retail Dutch Auction System (WDAS and RDAS) windows in a bid to curtail arbitraging or the so-called round tripping and speculative activity. These measures have failed spectacularly as the excess demand has poured into the parallel market, widening the exchange rate differential by as much as 100% at some point and thus expanding the incentive for arbitraging.

Many experts believe that the Naira should be devalued while others argue that the time has come for the CBN to abandon the fixed rate currency regime and allow the Naira to find its equilibrium levels which is believed will be somewhere between N250 to N260 as policy coherence replaces current uncertainties and enables the return of private sector foreign exchange, foreign direct investment and portfolio inflows to the official market. However, President Buhari has clearly stated that this is not an option for his APC government with its “change” mantra.

I sympathize with the CBN Governor and the President because they are caught between the devil and the deep blue sea. While the current official exchange rate is largely artificial does not reflect economic realities and the true value of the Naira, a sudden devaluation in the short term is likely to lead to even higher inflation, greater unemployment, more hardship for Nigerians and a significant risk of political unrest. The opposition would argue that this is not the sort of ‘change’ Nigerians voted for.

In any case, devaluation is only a temporary measure which does not fix the fundamentals. There are several fundamental factors that have contributed to the downward pressure on the Naira, and are still exerting a massive influence on the currency. Nigeria is undeniably an import-dependent economy. According to the National Bureau of Statistics, Nigeria’s import bill in 1984 was N167.88m, but in just the 2nd quarter of 2015, Nigeria spent N1.493trillion on imports. CNBC Africa also reported in an opinion write-up on its website on January 20, 2016, that Nigeria spends N1.3trillion importing food annually! Nigeria’s food import bill is said to be rising at a rate of 11% annually, according to data on the website of Doreo Partners.

The National Bureau of Statistics reported that the Federal Government spent about N1.82 trillion on importation of petroleum products between January and September 2015. Petroleum product imports accounts for 45% of the consumption of foreign exchange earned by the CBN, according to a recent interview granted to Silverbird TV by Comrade Peter Esele, former President of the Petroleum and Natural Gas Senior Staff Association of Nigeria (PENGASSAN). Some experts believe that the true figure is much higher. The Chairman of the Senate Committee on Tertiary Institution and Tertiary Education Trust Fund, TETFund, Senator Binta Masi, stated in January during the commissioning of a project at the Federal University Lafia that Nigeria spends over $2 billion annually on foreign education.

It is obvious that as long as Nigeria continues to spend colossal amounts of its foreign exchange earnings on consumption of foreign goods and services, there will always be a massive excess demand for foreign exchange to settle these transactions. Therefore, while devaluation of the Naira may eventually reduce the pressures on the external reserves held by the CBN and reduce round tripping by narrowing the exchange rate arbitrage gap; it will not solve the demand issue in the long term.

The CBN should work hard to encourage harmonization of its monetary policy with the Federal Government’s fiscal policies to encourage a shift in the nation’s status as an importing nation to that of an export-oriented country. No economy can operate on independent monetary or fiscal policies alone. There has to be a synergy of both monetary and fiscal policies for the Nigerian economic fundamentals to shift towards true, inclusive growth. For effective harmonization, there should be a more cordial relationship between the CBN and Ministry of Finance. The relationship should emphasize information sharing, cooperation and coordination of policies and more crucially, eliminate uncertainties that adversely affect investments.

With regard to monetary policy, economists are aware, there is an intricate link between interest rate, exchange rate and the general price level and the challenge is to establish optimum levels of these consistent with internal and external balances. Policy choices must be made as the three variables cannot be controlled simultaneously as it appears that CBN is attempting to do at the moment.

There are several broad measures the CBN and the FGN can put in place immediately to stabilize the currency, boost the economy and diversify the economy. Firstly, in the short term, the CBN would have to conserve the country’s foreign reserves by allowing the Naira to find its appropriate value through a free or at least managed float. Though crude oil prices have recovered somewhat to just above $40 a barrel, this does appear to be a temporary situation. The fundamentals in the crude oil global market have changed for the foreseeable future. The US has ended its 40-year moratorium on crude oil exports and is now pushing 9 million barrels of oil into the market daily, thanks to its shale exploration technology. Iran is also back into the market and understandably, has distanced itself from the production cuts now being pursued by OPEC. Saudi Arabia has a history of flouting OPEC production cuts and cannot be relied on to cooperate fully with the new initiative to reign in production anyway.

On the domestic front, pipeline vandalism and crude oil theft are still challenges that are preventing Nigeria from achieving its full production quota of 2.4million barrels per day. Nigeria is a long way from earning as much as it did from crude in 2011/2012 when the war in Libya was raging. Whatever meagre margins are being added to the foreign reserves cannot be expended trying to stabilize the local currency. Russia spent $76bn and €5bn trying to stabilize the Rouble in 2014 and was largely unsuccessful. Nigeria has no such luxury and therefore decisive action has to be taken now to allow the Naira to float or at least be devalued.

Devaluing the Naira now will automatically close the current ridiculous rate differential between the official exchange and the parallel market and eventually create a uniform exchange rate for the country. It will however have the negative effect of driving up inflation in the short term since it will cost more to purchase foreign goods and raw materials. However, this will also begin to spur some level of readjustment in terms of priorities of what we consume as a nation. While Nigeria will still have to import petroleum products and raw materials for certain industries for some time to come, there are other goods which are being produced in Nigeria and which can be used as import substitutes.

Secondly, we should no longer pay lip service to import substitution. This will however take time and the reality is that there are no short cuts. However, there has to be a conscious move to curtail the importation of items that are presently draining the country’s foreign exchange by promoting the local production of these items. The experience with the import bans on stockfish and wheat have shown that the way to go about curtailing imports is not outright prohibition, but more towards implementing monetary and fiscal policies which will enhance the capacity of local firms to produce these items in quantities that will serve local demand. Higher tariffs may have to be imposed on imports of certain items which will make them more expensive, potentially boost government revenue and provide a phased approach in the transition from the imported varieties of these items to local substitutes of equal or better quality.

Thirdly, a critical look needs to be taken on the importation of petroleum products. Presently, Alhaji Aliko Dangote is constructing a $16bn petroleum refinery in the Lekki Free Trade Zone, Lagos State which, when completed, will have the capacity to refine 650,000 barrels of crude oil per day and make Nigeria self-sufficient in terms of production of petroleum products. The Central Bank of Nigeria has already promised to ensure that the project receives foreign exchange needed to import critical components at the official exchange rate.

Though laudable, the CBN needs to expand this policy to encourage other local manufacturers of products presently being imported into Nigeria and to export-oriented industries with large employment absorptive capacities. The policy of providing forex at the official exchange rate to manufacturers who are willing to step up local production of items presently being imported while seemingly attractive, would be unnecessary when there is a convergence of official and unofficial rates. This would also eliminate a discretionary policy which if unchecked, could provide some with unfair advantages.

Finally, diversification of Nigeria’s economy is now a necessity. Diversification should not be viewed in terms of only expansion into mining and sale of solid minerals. The same collapse in oil prices hit the commodity markets even harder. Diversification should therefore be directed towards manufacturing, agriculture, technology and human capital development. Nigeria could look to a country like Norway in this regard. Both countries are oil producing countries and both have vibrant agricultural potentials.

The difference is that while Norway saves almost all its crude oil earnings in a sovereign wealth fund and sells its agricultural, fishing and manufactured products to the world, Nigeria has been spending all its crude oil earnings on imports and has allowed its manufacturing and agricultural sectors to wilt. Today, Norway boasts of foreign reserves of just under $58bn and a sovereign wealth fund worth $882bn. CNBC has identified Norway’s Government Pension Fund Global as the largest sovereign wealth fund in the world.

It is now painfully obvious that the PDP-led government of the last six years or so failed to plan for the long term development of the Nigerian economy, or at least failed to faithfully implement whatever plans it had. On the other hand, it is equally obvious that despite the rhetoric during the political campaigns, the current APC Federal Government had no discernible, coherent economic development plan before coming into office and still does not appear to have one almost a year after winning the elections. Unless this cluelessness changes, some may argues that they are planning to fail.

The path to growth of our economy is going to be arduous and will take time and quite frankly, there are no real short cuts. We must all share the pain. Devaluation alone is not the solution to our economic challenges. What is required now is a well articulated, holistic economic development plan which will then need to be sold to Nigerians to justify the obvious sacrifices that they will have to make to achieve the progress we seek and inculcate a unity of purpose.
•Edevbie is the Commissioner for Finance Delta State

  • Fovie Patrick O.

    Incisive and pithy. We need more intellectual-politicians like this, who discuss national issues irrespective of party affiliation. Import substitution is the way forward. The Nigerian state thrives on rent seeking, the citizens have learnt from the government, thus, the 2 superstructures of every economy(agriculture and manufacturing) are inchoate. Also, we must put an end to prebendalism, it has destroyed Nigeria’s reward system. The reward system must encourage intellectual, efficient, value adding and productive ventures. That way, there will be motivation to rebuild this economy.

    • amador kester

      Nice article,nice commentary. He hit the nail on the head when he stated that monetary policies ( even if they are temporary measures) cannot act independent of fiscal policies.The cbn governor cannot precipitate monetary and economic phantasmagoric miracle by also doing or rather inadvertently doing away with what the finance ministry should do. It goes without saying that he has marshalled out an array of substantive prescriptions and i dont care about who is or his party the important thing is that the prescribed remedies are non palliative and sound for the idiopathic econ malady ..But other pundits have equally prescribed all these before.We heard all these music before: the need to institute measure to convergent official and parallel exchange rates,import substitution,vertical integration,industrial transformation and what have you. Question is: do policy makers factor in all these in their econ implementation modalities? But lets be cautiously optimistic as we seem to have the tortoise slow temperament incapable of quantum leap transformation mentality. And hoping too that the $200 billion or 60,,000 naira loot recovered from some ex governors in dubai have been brought in ( as we could not save much in our reserves after 50 years of oil windfall unlike middle east nations with trillions of petrodollar reserves) . If the monumental loot is brought in why wont the naira par one on one to the dollar? And why cant the dollar ever chase the naira? Unless we are destined to be the noisy spectators of history and why should we be content with that?

  • William Norris

    Finally a government official making some sense.

    And of course it’s a PDP official.

    The fascist – socialist leaning of the APC will kill this country.

  • William Norris

    Anyone notice the QUALITATIVE difference between this article and the one submitted by the Finance Minister Adeosun? LOL !!!

    • FrankNinja

      First class analysis from a first class brain. He was wrong though about the impact. Poor monetary policy has KILLED private investment which was mostly externally driven. Devaluation is critical to Kickstart the economy along with keynesian govt spending. Nigeria is lucky that there is a lot of investment attractions. They should concession out airports, refineries and even free up gas pricing. The big dollars will flow in. But they are playing defense.

      • William Norris

        “Playing Defense” is indeed a good description; Adeosun and her Brainless Boss keep focusing on “plugging leakages” and “fighting corruption” to which I say it’s better to have corruption AND a much bigger economy where people can find jobs and have the FREEDOM to pursue the well being of their families.

        Yes they also say they want DIVERSIFICATION but it seems too dependent on government operational involvement. Their solution to fuel scarcity has been to INCREASE the role of NNPC in supplying the market by reducing the import licenses granted to private importers; there was a detailed report on that in Thisday just yesterday or so. Given that private operators are much more efficient it’s no surprise that scarcity has worsened.

        I’m just mystified by this government. I just don’t get it. Worst the Nigerian people don’t seem to have learned the lessons from the privatization & deregulation of telecoms, broadcasting, cement and airlines. Probably not aware that the current economic crisis is a DIRECT RESULT of the restoration of fuel subsidies in Jan 2012.

        I just don’t get it.

        • Itodo Okey Santos

          Would have loved it more if the writer drilled it down by linking part of our present economic mess with our refusal to do away with fuel subsidy in 2012. Pure economic problem was turned into a political opportunity by some people. Well, it is a pay back time. It’s just bad as both the innocents have to pay too!

          As for the economic benefits of privatization and deregulation, forget it. Buhari does not understand such economics. Didn’t you hear his comment over PHCN privatization during his recent economic summit opening speech? The truth is that Nigerians are in big time trouble.
          It is scary but it is real.
          How one intends to handle a modern economy with such economic myopic views of Buhari still baffles many.

          • Abia_Man

            Wasn’t he like a secretary to Yaradua when Yaradua reversing electricity energy reforms started by OBJ? I wonder if he advised the man then.

          • FrankNinja

            The problem with northern politicians is their very essence is tied to big government which is why Buhari was even talking about reviving a national airline. But no big government without big resources and big discipline. The state needs to step aside and be a minority shareholder in everything it runs.

            Look at Nigeria LNG successful because the long throat of Nigerian govt and their recruitment nepotism and penchant for fraud and theft was boxed out. They should sell off 60% of refineries which I am sure some of those deep pocketed equity or Arabian companies would love to have, and give the airport’s to companies that know how to run them not the jokers at faan. Then sit back and let change work it’s wonders in investment and tax.

          • amador kester

            Nigeria has to demystify the illusion or rather the grandiose delusion of big govt before it can transform from crony to entrepreneurial capitalism. The illusion of big govt is a monumental pathological trap and nigeria seems sucked in to point of no return

        • FrankNinja

          You need minimum standards of performance in govt to tolerate corruption. Nigeria has breached those standards. It’s govt is a termite hill full of thieves and armed robbers. So Buhari is on the right path there but the focus must not be just prosecution but deterrence. A lot of the civil service needs to be transitioned out. They should bring back civil service exams and clean out the rot. A lot of dead woods in govt.

          • amador kester

            Good and at las some sound econ recipes are wafting out of this forum

      • amador kester

        Thats the point. For long the prescriptive orchestra has been playing out these symphonies to high crescendo. But are policy makers dancing? Or even dancing on time? Thats the hot chocolate but we cannot drop this topic like hot potato. Until we get it 70 percent right and i dont think its up to 50 percent yet

  • Seyido

    What is new in the writers submission? The same content was presented in 1985 in IBBs regime and also in 1999 at the inauguration of OBJ’s regime. The writer was a principal officer in Yaradua’s regime, what attempt did he make to correct the anomalies?
    We always know how to write, but we lack the political will to do. Clearly, the writer made it clear that devaluation is not the be all and end all of policy making.
    Finally, the government has elucidated its position at different times, through different people. I think we Nigerians just love to either listen or read good grammar.